Irish Healthcare vs. Brazilian Healthcare: Comparative Guide for Curious

Moving abroad means adapting not only to new languages and weather, but also to new healthcare systems. For Brazilians living in Ireland—or for anyone curious about the contrasts—understanding how each country takes care of its people is a real necessity and reveals a lot about their values and challenges. Here’s an updated guide to the key differences, quirks, challenges, and historical background of healthcare in Brazil and Ireland.

1. A Brief History

Ireland:
Ireland’s healthcare system is a mix of public and private services. The public side, managed by the Health Service Executive (HSE), was officially established in 2005, though public healthcare dates back to the early 20th century. The system is inspired by the British NHS, but with more private involvement and less centralisation. Achieving universal access is an ongoing goal, but not yet fully realised.

Brazil:
Brazil’s healthcare system, known as SUS (Sistema Único de Saúde), was born in 1988 after years of social struggle and health inequality. SUS is one of the largest public health systems in the world, offering universal, free-at-the-point-of-care for all residents and even visitors. A strong private sector (health plans) exists too, especially for urban and wealthier populations.

2. Access and Eligibility

Ireland:
All residents can use public healthcare, but not all services are free. The HSE issues medical cards (full coverage for low-income or vulnerable people) and GP visit cards (free GP appointments, but medication must be paid for). Most people pay out of pocket for GP visits (€50–€75), unless they have one of these cards. Nearly half of Irish people also have private health insurance (Irish Life, VHI, Laya, etc).

Brazil:
Anyone—citizen, resident, or visitor—can use SUS for free. No insurance, no card, no fees. Private health plans can be purchased to access private clinics and hospitals, skip queues, and gain more comfort.

3. Primary Care (GPs and Health Clinics)

Ireland:
The GP (family doctor) is the first point of contact. Consultations are usually paid for, unless you have a medical or GP visit card. There are public health centres, but waiting lists for specialists can be long.

Brazil:
SUS provides Basic Health Units (UBS/PSF) with GPs, nurses, vaccinations, and sometimes dental care—all for free. Booking appointments and exams can take patience, especially in big cities or for specialist care. Private clinics offer faster service, but only for those who pay or have insurance.

4. Emergency and Hospitals

Ireland:
Emergency (A&E) care in public hospitals is free for genuine emergencies, but waiting times are notoriously long—hours are common. Private hospitals offer shorter waits, but are costly.

Brazil:
SUS offers free 24-hour emergency care in public hospitals (UPA, emergency rooms). Overcrowding and resource shortages are frequent issues, but basic care is always available. Private hospitals provide more comfort and speed, for a price or with insurance.

5. Medicines

Ireland:
Most medicines are not free. Medical card holders get nearly all prescriptions at no cost; others pay in full, but there’s a monthly cap (€80 in 2024—“Drugs Payment Scheme”). Pharmacies are everywhere, some offering free minor health services.

Brazil:
SUS provides many essential medicines for free (hypertension, diabetes, asthma, etc.). The “Farmácia Popular” programme offers free or discounted medicines for all. Private pharmacies are ubiquitous and often open 24/7 in large cities.

6. Maternal, Child, and Preventive Care

Ireland:
Maternity, birth, and early childhood care are priorities—public services are free for pregnant women, new mothers, and children. Childhood vaccines are free and widely available.

Brazil:
SUS covers prenatal, childbirth, and vaccinations for free. Brazil’s vaccination programme is considered one of the best in the world.

7. Challenges and Curiosities

Ireland:

• Long waiting lists for specialists—months or even years.

• Shortage of doctors—rural areas often lack GPs.

• Mental health services are improving, but demand has soared since the pandemic.

Brazil:

• Underfunding: SUS constantly struggles with limited budgets.

• Regional inequality: Service quality varies widely between regions.

• Innovation: Telemedicine and mobile health units have expanded, especially post-pandemic.

Curiosities:

• Brazil’s SUS card system is a model for universal health data in other developing countries.

• Ireland has the highest rate of private health insurance in the EU after the Netherlands.

8. Costs — Overview

9. Main Differences — Table

10. Personal Reflection: My Experience in Both Systems

In Brazil, I didn’t have private health insurance as a child—I relied on SUS. Once I started working, I got a private health plan. The private health insurance market in Brazil is massive, with a huge range of options and prices. If you have a private plan, you don’t pay extra for consultations or exams within the plan’s network—it’s all included in your monthly fee. You only claim reimbursement if you choose to see a doctor outside your network, but that’s rare, because there are so many options and specialists available.

In Ireland, it’s completely different—even with private health insurance, you pay for each consultation up front and only later claim reimbursement. The amount per visit is high, and getting your money back isn’t instant. Plus, you can’t choose a specialist directly: everyone has to go through a GP first, who decides if you’ll get a referral. This slows everything down.

In Brazil, you can book a specialist directly, without a family doctor in between, and often get an appointment the same day or next day, especially in big cities. This speed just doesn’t exist in Ireland, which suffers from a shortage of doctors and long delays—whether you’re using public or private care.

Another key difference: in Brazil, test results are usually available online, and you can access, print and share them with any doctor you want. In Ireland, patients rarely get direct access, and information isn’t easily shared between doctors.

Having experienced a good private plan in Brazil, I feel the difference sharply in Ireland—I actually prefer the Brazilian system for its speed, variety and accessibility, even acknowledging SUS’s problems. But my move to Ireland wasn’t about healthcare. I’m simply learning to navigate a much slower, more bureaucratic system, adapting day by day.

Both Ireland and Brazil mix public and private healthcare, but with very different philosophies. Brazil’s system is universal and unconditional, but faces underfunding and logistical issues. Ireland seeks fairness but blends public and private, with many costs still paid by citizens. No system is perfect—both are evolving to meet people’s needs.

FAQ

Q: Is healthcare free in Ireland?
A: Only for those with a medical card or certain groups. Most people pay for GP visits, but emergency care is free if urgent.

Q: Is healthcare free in Brazil?
A: Yes, the SUS system offers universal free healthcare for anyone, including non-citizens.

Q: Do I need insurance in Ireland?
A: Not required, but nearly half the population has private health insurance for faster access and more comfort.

Q: Are medicines free in both countries?
A: Most medicines are free through SUS in Brazil. In Ireland, prescriptions are only free for those with a medical card; otherwise, you pay (with a monthly cap).

Q: Which country has better healthcare?
A: Both have strengths and challenges. Brazil’s system is more universal; Ireland’s has better access to private services, but more out-of-pocket costs.

What’s the craic? More soul, more stories, right this way:

• My Urban Wellbeing Blog: Where Real Life Meets Soul